Italy fined Meta €805 million on Saturday, about $887 million, after finding that Facebook’s Android app reached into users’ photo galleries without their specific consent. The decision came from Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante, and it ranks among the largest penalties an Italian regulator has ever handed a tech company.
At the center of the case is a feature called “Get suggestions from your gallery,” which has been live since 2023. As people browse Facebook, it offers photos and videos from their phone’s gallery as ideas for posts. Around 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, according to the regulator.
Meta says it will appeal. A company spokesperson called the penalty “disproportionate.”
How Facebook’s gallery feature triggered the Meta Italy fine
Facebook asked for gallery access through a single permission that covered the whole app. Users saw a generic notice about enabling “other features” before granting it. Nothing in that prompt made clear they were also agreeing to let Facebook scan their gallery and turn its contents into post suggestions, the Garante said.
That gap is the whole case. Italian privacy rules require separate, specific consent for this kind of access, and the authority found Meta never got it. In its statement, the regulator said Meta gained access to Italian users’ photographs, videos and associated metadata “without having obtained specific consent and without having duly informed them.”
Investigators also weighed Meta’s conduct during the probe. When setting the amount, the authority pointed to the large number of people affected, the length of the violation, and what it described as Meta’s limited cooperation during the investigation. It noted the problem is still live for people who have not updated the app and for those who already granted the permission.
What Meta has to do now
Meta has 60 days to switch the feature off by default in Italy and to ask users for a separate, specific yes before it can run again. Any new consent request has to spell out what the feature does, that it involves access to the gallery, and how to turn it off.
That’s a bigger change than it sounds. A feature that quietly ran in the background for three years now has to ask permission out loud, one user at a time. People who never agreed will simply stop seeing gallery suggestions.
The Garante also kept a second door open. It reserved the right to look separately at a newer feature, introduced in 2026, that sends gallery content to the cloud for processing. That could produce a second decision on the same part of the app.
One thing the investigation did not cover: whether photos pulled in through the feature were used to train AI models. Regulators said that question was outside the scope of this case, and Meta has denied using the material that way.
Why the number is so big
€805 million sounds huge until you set it against Meta’s scale. The company turned over $201 billion in 2025 and posted a net profit of $60.5 billion. Against that, the fine works out to around 0.4% of annual turnover. European privacy law allows fines up to 4% of global revenue, so Italy stayed well short of the ceiling.
Still, the figure puts Meta in rare company. Only one Italian penalty against a tech firm has been larger: Amazon’s €1.1 billion competition fine in 2021, which was later cut to €752 million on appeal. Meta can appeal too, and given its public stance, it almost certainly will.
The case also lands weeks after a much bigger hit in the United States. At the end of October, Meta was ordered to pay $25 billion in New Mexico for misleading residents about how their data was used over more than a decade. Meta denounced that penalty as a “tax” on freedom of expression. The two cases are separate, but together they show regulators on both sides of the Atlantic pressing the same point: a single vague permission is not consent.
What this means for users outside Italy
Nothing in the Italian order applies directly to Facebook users in the United States. The feature, the fine and the 60-day fix are all limited to Italy. But the logic travels. If a consent screen that buries gallery access inside a general app permission fails in Rome, it is hard to see how the same design survives scrutiny anywhere else in Europe.
For Meta, the timing is awkward. The company is pushing hard into AI features that need access to personal photos and video, including tools that process gallery content in the cloud. Every new feature like that now arrives with a regulator watching and a recent €805 million example of what happens when the consent screen doesn’t say enough.
For users, the lesson is simpler and worth acting on. Check which apps on your phone can read your photo gallery, and whether you remember agreeing to each one. On Android, that takes about a minute in Settings under Privacy. A permission granted three years ago for one reason can quietly cover a very different one today.
Frequently asked questions
Why was Meta fined in Italy?
Facebook’s Android app accessed photos, videos and metadata in users’ galleries without their specific consent, through a photo-suggestion feature that was switched on by default since 2023.
How much is the Meta Italy fine?
The fine is €805 million, about $887 million. Italy’s regulator says that is roughly 0.4% of Meta’s $201 billion annual turnover in 2025.
How many people were affected by the Facebook gallery feature?
About 20 million Android users in Italy were affected, according to Italy’s data protection authority, the Garante.
Will Meta appeal the Italy fine?
Yes. Meta says it will appeal and called the penalty “disproportionate.” It has 60 days to switch the feature off by default and ask users for separate consent.
Sources: Reuters, BBC, Le Temps, Gulf News, PYMNTS.
